Newcastle vs Arsenal: Guimaraes Left Newcastle as Captain. He Comes Back Five Points Clear at the Top

by Geoffrey Ejiga | by Geoffrey Ejiga

image Newcastle vs Arsenal: Guimaraes Left Newcastle as Captain. He Comes Back Five Points Clear at the Top
Newcastle sold Bruno Guimaraes to Arsenal for £75 million in August. Tonight he walks back into St James' Park for the first time, five points clear at the top of the Premier League. The club he left is 12th and hasn't scored at home in two matches.
Enjoying SportyTrader content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account!

"Thank You Will Never Be Enough"

That was what Bruno Guimaraes wrote in his farewell letter to Newcastle in August, the day Arsenal completed a £75 million deal to take him south.

He had spent four and a half years at the club, made 195 appearances, scored 31 goals and set up 31 more. Bruno captained Eddie Howe's side to the League Cup trophy win over Liverpool, marking their first domestic trophy in 70 years.

"I fell in love with this place," he wrote. And then, in the same letter: "I wanted to experience something new."

So tonight, for the 200th competitive meeting between these two clubs, Guimaraes walks back into St James' Park for the first time since the move.

Only now he is wearing Arsenal red, sitting in a midfield alongside Declan Rice and Martin Odegaard, and helping defend a Premier League title that the club he left behind is nowhere near challenging.

Joelinton, his former teammate and close friend, has already delivered the welcome: "Just when he comes here now, he can't have a good time!" Though Joelinton himself has not featured all season because of injury and will not be on the pitch to enforce it.

Matthias Jaissle, the man hired to replace Howe, tried a different line. "I tried my best," the Newcastle manager said. "But the decision was made. So now we are opponents and competitors."

What Newcastle Became After He Left

It happened fast. In one summer, Newcastle lost their manager, their captain and two of their best attackers:

  • Howe resigned in July after a 2025-26 season that ended with 17 league defeats and a 12th-place finish, citing a need to "recharge" after nearly five years in charge.
  • Guimaraes went to Arsenal.
  • Anthony Gordon was sold to Barcelona.
  • Sandro Tonali joined Tottenham.

The replacements? Young, largely unproven, and so far, struggling.

Jaissle, the 38-year-old German hired from Al Ahli, walked into a rebuild he did not design. Three wins from 10 league games and sitting 12th in the table on 12 points, the same position they finished last season.

And they arrived having failed to score in their last two home matches, while carrying seven home league defeats in 2026 (joint-most in the division).

And the numbers only get worse the closer you look. Newcastle have won just one of their last 29 league games against the team sitting top of the table at kickoff.

What’s more, The Magpies have not beaten the reigning Premier League champions since a 2-1 win over Manchester City in January 2019.

"I am responsible for that," Jaissle said after their latest home defeat, a 1-0 loss to Everton. "If you cannot deliver when it counts then you don't deserve to win."

Whether the new gaffer can chart a new course is something our experts answer in the Newcastle vs Arsenal prediction.

Newcastle

Arsenal

Position12th1st
Points (10 games)1227
League record3W 3D 4L9W 0D 1L
Clean sheets37
Goals conceded165 (fewest in PL)
Last 4 head-to-head0 wins4 wins

Arsenal Keep Winning Without Their Best Player

Arsenal, meanwhile, are having a blast at the top, having bagged 27 points from 10 EPL games.

Only four teams in Premier League history have collected more at this stage, and every one of them won the title.

Fun fact: Arteta's side are three points ahead of where the Invincibles were after the same number of matches in 2003-04.

And they are doing it without Bukayo Saka, who has been out with a quad injury since late October and will miss tonight. Martin Zubimendi is also sidelined with a hamstring problem. And youngster Max Dowman is suspended.

What Arsenal do have is the best defence in the country, boasting seven clean sheets (the most) and just five goals conceded (the fewest).

The last time Arsenal visited St James' Park, in September 2025, Gabriel headed a winner in the sixth minute of stoppage time to steal a 2-1 comeback. Guimaraes was still wearing black and white that night. Tonight he comes back through the away dressing room.

One stat captures the whole story. In his four and a half years at Newcastle, Guimaraes covered 98.6 kilometres, won 71 duels and committed 17 fouls in matches against Arsenal. More than against any other opponent. The team that brought the absolute best out of him went and bought him.