Arizona Cardinals vs Indianapolis Colts Prediction & Picks - NFL

Prediction published on 10/12/25, 9:55 AM  by Erik Gibbs | Modified on 10/12/25 at 4:10 PM in NFL Picks

The Arizona Cardinals and Indianapolis Colts square off on Sunday in a game marked by vastly different storylines. For Arizona, the trip to Indianapolis comes on the heels of one of the most crushing defeats in franchise memory. The Cardinals held a 22–8 lead over Tennessee late in the fourth quarter when running back Emari Demercado appeared to break free for a 72-yard touchdown that would have sealed the win. Instead, he dropped the ball inches before crossing the goal line, and the Titans capitalized on the error—staging a dramatic 16-point comeback to steal a 22–21 victory.

Head coach Jonathan Gannon was visibly furious on the sidelines, berating Demercado in front of teammates and cameras before later apologizing for his outburst. The emotional exchange symbolized the team’s broader frustrations with a season full of near-misses. The loss also left Arizona battered physically. Quarterback Kyler Murray left the game with a toe injury and is currently listed as questionable. Tight end Tip Reiman (ankle) and linebacker Cody Simon (knee) have both been ruled out, leaving major holes on both sides of the ball.

Meanwhile, Indianapolis continues to defy early-season skeptics. The Colts are 4–1 after dismantling the Raiders 40–6, cementing themselves as legitimate AFC South contenders. Their offense has been lethal in the red zone—leading the league with 12 touchdowns in goal-to-go situations—and quarterback Daniel Jones is experiencing a resurgence. With 1,290 passing yards and a 71.3% completion rate, he’s been both accurate and efficient. Running back Jonathan Taylor continues to thrive, scoring three touchdowns last week as the offense clicked on all cylinders.