New York Yankees vs Tampa Bay Rays Prediction & Picks - MLB

USA - MLB

New York Yankees
9/23/26 19:05
Tampa Bay Rays

Prediction:

 

Over 6.5 Runs

−115
$200 offered for betting!

New customers only | Commercial content | 21+ age limit | T&Cs apply

 by Lou Aguila | in MLB Picks

The New York Yankees and the Tampa Bay Rays clash in Game 3 of their series.

Bettors can take advantage of a much lower total for this game at over/under 6.0 runs as struggling starters Gerrit Cole and Ian Seymour take the mound again.

Current Form:

The Tampa Bay Rays have gone 3-1 in their last four games to lock up the AL East title. Over the last five games, the Rays have displayed elite pitching with a 1.84 ERA.

As for the New York Yankees, their chance of stealing the AL East title from the Rays slipped away after dropping 3 of their last 4 games, including a 1-6 loss in Game 2 of this series. Since their 9-2 win over Arizona, the Yankees have not scored more than five runs in each of their last four games.

Starting Pitchers: Yankees RHP Gerrit Cole (9-9, 3.63 ERA) vs. Rays LHP Ian Seymour (9-7, 4.38 ERA).

The Matchup: Total has gone OVER in 3 of the last 5 meetings between the Yankees and the Rays.

Conviction of the Day

Our editorial team's top-confidence pick, every day.

Members only · free sign-up

Sign up for free

New York Yankees vs Tampa Bay Rays Form

Table

Teams Pts P W L
3 Tampa Bay Rays
0.605 162 98 64
5 New York Yankees
0.578 161 93 68

New York Yankees and Tampa Bay Rays Latest Matches

New York Yankees
New York Yankees Latest matches
L W L L W L
Victories

2/6 (33%)

Defeats

4/6 (67%)

Sep 22, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
1 :  6
Tampa Bay Rays

Sep 22, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
2 :  0
Tampa Bay Rays

Sep 20, 2026 - MLB

Arizona Diamondbacks
8 :  4
New York Yankees

Sep 19, 2026 - MLB

Arizona Diamondbacks
5 :  3
New York Yankees

Sep 18, 2026 - MLB

Arizona Diamondbacks
2 :  9
New York Yankees

Sep 16, 2026 - MLB

Minnesota Twins
5 :  4
New York Yankees
W W L W W L
Victories

4/6 (67%)

Defeats

2/6 (33%)

Sep 22, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
1 :  6
Tampa Bay Rays

Sep 22, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
2 :  0
Tampa Bay Rays

Sep 13, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
2 :  0
New York Mets

Sep 12, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
2 :  12
New York Mets

Sep 11, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
6 :  4
New York Mets

Sep 10, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
10 :  3
Colorado Rockies
W W L W L L
Victories

3/6 (50%)

Defeats

3/6 (50%)

Sep 20, 2026 - MLB

Arizona Diamondbacks
8 :  4
New York Yankees

Sep 19, 2026 - MLB

Arizona Diamondbacks
5 :  3
New York Yankees

Sep 18, 2026 - MLB

Arizona Diamondbacks
2 :  9
New York Yankees

Sep 16, 2026 - MLB

Minnesota Twins
5 :  4
New York Yankees

Sep 15, 2026 - MLB

Minnesota Twins
1 :  8
New York Yankees

Sep 14, 2026 - MLB

Minnesota Twins
3 :  8
New York Yankees
Tampa Bay Rays
Tampa Bay Rays Latest matches
W L W W L W
Victories

4/6 (67%)

Defeats

2/6 (33%)

Sep 22, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
1 :  6
Tampa Bay Rays

Sep 22, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
2 :  0
Tampa Bay Rays

Sep 20, 2026 - MLB

Tampa Bay Rays
5 :  1
Boston Red Sox

Sep 19, 2026 - MLB

Tampa Bay Rays
2 :  1
Boston Red Sox

Sep 18, 2026 - MLB

Tampa Bay Rays
2 :  4
Boston Red Sox

Sep 17, 2026 - MLB

Tampa Bay Rays
10 :  1
Athletics
W W W L W W
Victories

5/6 (83%)

Defeats

1/6 (17%)

Sep 20, 2026 - MLB

Tampa Bay Rays
5 :  1
Boston Red Sox

Sep 19, 2026 - MLB

Tampa Bay Rays
2 :  1
Boston Red Sox

Sep 18, 2026 - MLB

Tampa Bay Rays
2 :  4
Boston Red Sox

Sep 17, 2026 - MLB

Tampa Bay Rays
10 :  1
Athletics

Sep 16, 2026 - MLB

Tampa Bay Rays
4 :  3
Athletics

Sep 15, 2026 - MLB

Tampa Bay Rays
2 :  1
Athletics
L W W L L W
Victories

3/6 (50%)

Defeats

3/6 (50%)

Sep 22, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
1 :  6
Tampa Bay Rays

Sep 22, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
2 :  0
Tampa Bay Rays

Sep 10, 2026 - MLB

Atlanta Braves
3 :  1
Tampa Bay Rays

Sep 9, 2026 - MLB

Atlanta Braves
2 :  7
Tampa Bay Rays

Sep 8, 2026 - MLB

Atlanta Braves
1 :  7
Tampa Bay Rays

Sep 6, 2026 - MLB

Texas Rangers
8 :  6
Tampa Bay Rays

New York Yankees against Tampa Bay Rays : Head to Head (H2H)

New York Yankees

50 %

Tampa Bay Rays

50 %

Sep 22, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
1 :  6
Tampa Bay Rays

Sep 22, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
2 :  0
Tampa Bay Rays

Jul 9, 2026 - MLB

Tampa Bay Rays
4 :  12
New York Yankees

Jul 8, 2026 - MLB

Tampa Bay Rays
3 :  0
New York Yankees

Jul 7, 2026 - MLB

Tampa Bay Rays
6 :  4
New York Yankees

Jul 6, 2026 - MLB

Tampa Bay Rays
1 :  5
New York Yankees
New York Yankees vs Tampa Bay Rays Picks

New York Yankees - Tampa Bay Rays Key Points

  1. Over is 3-0-1 in Gerrit Cole’s last 4 starts overall.
  2. Over is 6-1-1 in the Yankees' last 8 games as an underdog.
  3. The Yankees average 7.0 runs against left-handed pitchers over their last five games.
  4. Yankees Gerrit Cole surrendered 3 runs and 7 hits in a 0-3 loss to Tampa Bay on July 8, 2026

Our New York Yankees vs Tampa Bay Rays Prediction

Key Stats: Both starting pitchers have posted an ERA above 5.00 over their last five games. Cole has registered a 5.34 ERA, while Seymour has pitched to 5.33 ERA in their last five mound assignments.

What to Expect: Offense will prevail in Game 3 of this series. The starting pitchers have been unreliable over their past starts, which leaves them vulnerable to both teams’ batting corps.

The Rays are only averaging 1.3 runs against right-handed pitchers over the last five games, but the Yankees have produced 7 runs a game against left-handed hurlers over their last five games.

DraftKings has also taken some risk by lowering the total for this game to 6.5 runs despite the recent form of Cole and Seymour.

Fearless Forecast: the Yankees 6, the Rays 4

Our betting prediction for the New York Yankees vs. the Tampa Bay Rays: Over 6.5 Runs

Prediction:

 

Over 6.5 Runs

−115
$200 offered for betting!

A Welcome Bonus for New York Yankees vs Tampa Bay Rays!

DraftKings Welcome Bonus 200

Looking to place a bet on New York Yankees vs Tampa Bay Rays? For this MLB match, DraftKings will treat you to an exclusive offer: $200 in bonus bets, no promo code needed! Take advantage while you still can!

$200 in bonus bets for New York Yankees vs Tampa Bay Rays!

All tips are fully researched and given in good faith, but profits cannot be guaranteed.