New York Yankees vs New York Mets Prediction & Picks - MLB

USA - MLB

New York Yankees
9/12/26 13:35
New York Mets

Prediction:

 

Yankees to win and over 8.5 runs

+196
$250 offered for betting!

New customers only | Commercial content | 21+ age limit | T&Cs apply

 by Simon Day | in MLB Picks

The latest Subway Series continues on Saturday afternoon, as the Yankees attempt to make it two wins from two against the Mets and keep up the pressure on the Tampa Bay Rays at the top of the AL East table. 

In Friday's series opener, a three run homer from Cody Bellinger enabled the Yankees to establish a big early lead. The Mets battled hard to get back into the game, but despite scoring in each of their final three innings, they were unable to erase their deficit and eventually fell to a 6-4 defeat. 

With that victory, the Yankees moved to 85-62 for the season and are now just three games back from the Rays. Meanwhile, the Mets slipped to 68-79 and, despite their improved form over the last month, they have little to play for in the remaining weeks of the regular season. 

Up to $250 to bet on New York Yankees - New York Mets! 

Limited Offer. Currently at Caesars Sportsbook

New York Yankees vs New York Mets Form

Table

Teams Pts P W L
5 New York Yankees
0.578 147 85 62
23 New York Mets
0.463 147 68 79

New York Yankees and New York Mets Latest Matches

New York Yankees
New York Yankees Latest matches
W L W W W W
Victories

5/6 (83%)

Defeats

1/6 (17%)

Sep 11, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
6 :  4
New York Mets

Sep 10, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
10 :  3
Colorado Rockies

Sep 9, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
6 :  1
Colorado Rockies

Sep 8, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
5 :  3
Colorado Rockies

Sep 6, 2026 - MLB

San Diego Padres
4 :  3
New York Yankees

Sep 5, 2026 - MLB

San Diego Padres
1 :  5
New York Yankees
W W W W W W
Victories

6/6 (100%)

Defeats

0/6 (0%)

Sep 11, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
6 :  4
New York Mets

Sep 10, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
10 :  3
Colorado Rockies

Sep 9, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
6 :  1
Colorado Rockies

Sep 8, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
5 :  3
Colorado Rockies

Aug 30, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
16 :  1
Boston Red Sox

Aug 29, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
9 :  2
Boston Red Sox
L W W L W L
Victories

3/6 (50%)

Defeats

3/6 (50%)

Sep 6, 2026 - MLB

San Diego Padres
4 :  3
New York Yankees

Sep 5, 2026 - MLB

San Diego Padres
1 :  5
New York Yankees

Sep 4, 2026 - MLB

San Diego Padres
3 :  2
New York Yankees

Sep 2, 2026 - MLB

Los Angeles Angels
3 :  6
New York Yankees

Sep 1, 2026 - MLB

Los Angeles Angels
3 :  7
New York Yankees

Aug 31, 2026 - MLB

Los Angeles Angels
10 :  1
New York Yankees
New York Mets
New York Mets Latest matches
L W W W W L
Victories

4/6 (67%)

Defeats

2/6 (33%)

Sep 11, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
6 :  4
New York Mets

Sep 9, 2026 - MLB

Miami Marlins
14 :  15
New York Mets

Sep 8, 2026 - MLB

Miami Marlins
5 :  7
New York Mets

Sep 7, 2026 - MLB

Miami Marlins
4 :  9
New York Mets

Sep 6, 2026 - MLB

New York Mets
4 :  2
San Francisco Giants

Sep 5, 2026 - MLB

New York Mets
5 :  9
San Francisco Giants
L W L W L W
Victories

3/6 (50%)

Defeats

3/6 (50%)

Sep 6, 2026 - MLB

New York Mets
4 :  2
San Francisco Giants

Sep 5, 2026 - MLB

New York Mets
5 :  9
San Francisco Giants

Sep 4, 2026 - MLB

New York Mets
10 :  6
San Francisco Giants

Aug 30, 2026 - MLB

New York Mets
3 :  6
Houston Astros

Aug 29, 2026 - MLB

New York Mets
6 :  2
Houston Astros

Aug 28, 2026 - MLB

New York Mets
1 :  3
Houston Astros
L W W W W L
Victories

4/6 (67%)

Defeats

2/6 (33%)

Sep 11, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
6 :  4
New York Mets

Sep 9, 2026 - MLB

Miami Marlins
14 :  15
New York Mets

Sep 8, 2026 - MLB

Miami Marlins
5 :  7
New York Mets

Sep 7, 2026 - MLB

Miami Marlins
4 :  9
New York Mets

Sep 2, 2026 - MLB

Tampa Bay Rays
4 :  10
New York Mets

Sep 1, 2026 - MLB

Tampa Bay Rays
6 :  2
New York Mets

New York Yankees against New York Mets : Head to Head (H2H)

New York Yankees

33 %

New York Mets

67 %

Sep 11, 2026 - MLB

New York Yankees
6 :  4
New York Mets

May 17, 2026 - MLB

New York Mets
7 :  6
New York Yankees

May 16, 2026 - MLB

New York Mets
6 :  3
New York Yankees

May 15, 2026 - MLB

New York Mets
2 :  5
New York Yankees

Mar 8, 2026 - MLB Spring Training

New York Mets
10 :  4
New York Yankees

Feb 22, 2026 - MLB Spring Training

New York Yankees
4 :  6
New York Mets
New York Yankees vs New York Mets Picks

New York Yankees - New York Mets Key Points

  1. The Yankees are on a 4 game winning streak
  2. The Yankees have won their last 6 home games
  3. The Mets are 34-39 on the road this season
  4. The Yankees are 41-31 are home this season
Up to $250 to bet on New York Yankees - New York Mets! 

Limited Offer. Currently at Caesars Sportsbook

Our New York Yankees vs New York Mets Prediction

The Yankees have scored 27 runs in their last four games, whilst the Mets have managed a whopping 34 runs over the same period. In short, these are two sides stacked with in-form big hitters, so we are expecting plenty of runs on Saturday afternoon. 

As for picking a winner, this looks like it will be another tight game, but the Yankees' overall depth should be enough to get the job done, so our prediction is a home win in a high scoring contest. 

Our prediction for New York Yankees vs New York Mets is: Yankees to win and over 8.5 runs.

Prediction:

 

Yankees to win and over 8.5 runs

+196
$250 offered for betting!

Caesars Rewards Program

Caesars Rewards

Caesars Sportsbook really spoils new users with an awesome rewards program, making every wager count towards something bigger! Available for users across the country, this program is a bettor's dream. As you enjoy the thrills of sports betting or casino games online, you can earn up to 10 Reward Credits for every $100 wagered on straight bets. And if parlays are more your style, you'll earn up to 20 Reward Credits for every $100 wagered. With Caesars Sportsbook, your bets not only bring the excitement of the game but also the joy of accumulating rewards that enhance your gaming experience. Play now and let Caesars treat you like royalty with each bet you place!

Sign-up now!

All tips are fully researched and given in good faith, but profits cannot be guaranteed.