New York Rangers vs New York Islanders Prediction & Picks - NHL

USA - NHL

New York Rangers
10/6/26 19:30
New York Islanders

Prediction:

 

Rangers to win and under 6.5 goals

+295
$150 offered for betting!

New customers only | Commercial content | 21+ age limit | T&Cs apply

 by Simon Day in NHL Picks

The New York Rangers will be aiming to make it three wins on the spin when they take on fierce rivals the New York Islanders at MSG on Tuesday night. 

After dropping their season opener to the Boston Bruins, the Rangers have been on a tear up. They demolished Tampa Bay 5-1, then comfortably beat Detroit 2-0, before firing in three goals in the third period to edge out Utah 4-2. Expectations are fairly low for the Rangers this season, but that could all change if they can continue their bright start. 

The Islanders have played just two games so far: a narrow 2-1 loss in Toronto, followed by a thumping 6-0 success against a dire New Jersey Devils side.

Few experts are predicting either of the New York franchises to reach the playoffs this season, but the Battle of New York is always an intense and hard fought battle, so we are expecting plenty of fireworks at the Garden on Tuesday night. 

New York Rangers vs New York Islanders Form

Table

Teams Pts P W L GD
1 New York Rangers
6 4 3 1 +5
18 New York Islanders
2 2 1 1 +5

New York Rangers and New York Islanders Latest Matches

New York Rangers
New York Rangers Latest matches
L W L W W W
Victories

4/6 (67%)

Defeats

2/6 (33%)

Oct 4, 2026 - NHL

New York Rangers
4 :  2
Utah Mammoth

Oct 2, 2026 - NHL

Detroit Red Wings
0 :  2
New York Rangers

Oct 1, 2026 - NHL

New York Rangers
5 :  1
Tampa Bay Lightning

Sep 29, 2026 - NHL

Boston Bruins
3 :  0
New York Rangers

Apr 15, 2026 - NHL

Tampa Bay Lightning
2 :  4
New York Rangers

Apr 13, 2026 - NHL

Florida Panthers
3 :  2
New York Rangers
L W W L W W
Victories

4/6 (67%)

Defeats

2/6 (33%)

Oct 4, 2026 - NHL

New York Rangers
4 :  2
Utah Mammoth

Oct 1, 2026 - NHL

New York Rangers
5 :  1
Tampa Bay Lightning

Apr 8, 2026 - NHL

New York Rangers
3 :  5
Buffalo Sabres

Apr 5, 2026 - NHL

New York Rangers
8 :  1
Washington Capitals

Apr 4, 2026 - NHL

New York Rangers
4 :  1
Detroit Red Wings

Apr 2, 2026 - NHL

New York Rangers
2 :  3
Montreal Canadiens
L L L W L W
Victories

2/6 (33%)

Defeats

4/6 (67%)

Oct 2, 2026 - NHL

Detroit Red Wings
0 :  2
New York Rangers

Sep 29, 2026 - NHL

Boston Bruins
3 :  0
New York Rangers

Apr 15, 2026 - NHL

Tampa Bay Lightning
2 :  4
New York Rangers

Apr 13, 2026 - NHL

Florida Panthers
3 :  2
New York Rangers

Apr 11, 2026 - NHL

Dallas Stars
2 :  0
New York Rangers

Mar 25, 2026 - NHL

Toronto Maple Leafs
4 :  3
New York Rangers
New York Islanders
New York Islanders Latest matches
W L L L L W
Victories

2/6 (33%)

Defeats

4/6 (67%)

Oct 3, 2026 - NHL

New York Islanders
6 :  0
New Jersey Devils

Sep 30, 2026 - NHL

Toronto Maple Leafs
2 :  1
New York Islanders

Apr 14, 2026 - NHL

New York Islanders
1 :  2
Carolina Hurricanes

Apr 12, 2026 - NHL

New York Islanders
1 :  4
Montreal Canadiens

Apr 11, 2026 - NHL

New York Islanders
0 :  3
Ottawa Senators

Apr 9, 2026 - NHL

New York Islanders
5 :  3
Toronto Maple Leafs
L W L L L W
Victories

2/6 (33%)

Defeats

4/6 (67%)

Oct 3, 2026 - NHL

New York Islanders
6 :  0
New Jersey Devils

Apr 14, 2026 - NHL

New York Islanders
1 :  2
Carolina Hurricanes

Apr 12, 2026 - NHL

New York Islanders
1 :  4
Montreal Canadiens

Apr 11, 2026 - NHL

New York Islanders
0 :  3
Ottawa Senators

Apr 9, 2026 - NHL

New York Islanders
5 :  3
Toronto Maple Leafs

Apr 3, 2026 - NHL

New York Islanders
1 :  4
Philadelphia Flyers
W L L L L L
Victories

1/6 (17%)

Defeats

5/6 (83%)

Sep 30, 2026 - NHL

Toronto Maple Leafs
2 :  1
New York Islanders

Apr 4, 2026 - NHL

Carolina Hurricanes
4 :  3
New York Islanders

Mar 31, 2026 - NHL

Buffalo Sabres
4 :  3
New York Islanders

Mar 21, 2026 - NHL

Montreal Canadiens
7 :  3
New York Islanders

Mar 19, 2026 - NHL

Ottawa Senators
3 :  2
New York Islanders

Mar 17, 2026 - NHL

Toronto Maple Leafs
1 :  3
New York Islanders

New York Rangers against New York Islanders : Head to Head (H2H)

New York Rangers

33 %

New York Islanders

67 %

Jan 29, 2026 - NHL

New York Rangers
1 :  2
New York Islanders

Jan 28, 2026 - NHL

New York Islanders
5 :  2
New York Rangers

Dec 27, 2025 - NHL

New York Islanders
2 :  0
New York Rangers

Nov 8, 2025 - NHL

New York Rangers
0 :  5
New York Islanders

Apr 10, 2025 - NHL

New York Islanders
2 :  9
New York Rangers

Mar 3, 2025 - NHL

New York Rangers
4 :  0
New York Islanders
New York Rangers vs New York Islanders Picks

Players list

New York Rangers
New York Rangers

I. Shesterkin

D. Garand

A. Fox

V. Gavrikov

M. Pettersson

S. Durzi

B. Schneider

A. Smits

J. Veleno

E. Tolvanen

O. Bjorkstrand

J. Miller

P. Dorofeyev

G. Perreault

N. Laba

T. Kartye

J. Chmelar

W. Cuylle

A. Lafreniere

M. Zibanejad

New York Islanders
New York Islanders

S. Varlamov

I. Sorokin

M. Schaefer

R. Pulock

T. DeAngelo

A. Pelech

A. Romanov

L. Stanley

A. Duclair

B. Horvat

J. Pageau

O. Palat

C. Cizikas

K. Palmieri

B. Schenn

V. Eklund

C. Ritchie

E. Heineman

M. Maccelli

S. Holmstrom

Most goals and assists

CD Huachipato New York Rangers
CD Huachipato New York Islanders
Top Goalscorer
Finland E. Tolvanen (3 Goals)
Top Goalscorer
Sweden E. Heineman (1 Goals) ,  Canada B. Schenn (1 Goals) ,  Canada C. Cizikas (1 Goals) ,  Czech Republic O. Palat (1 Goals) ,  Canada B. Horvat (1 Goals) ,  Sweden S. Holmstrom (1 Goals) ,  Sweden V. Eklund (1 Goals)
Best assists
USA A. Fox (4 Assists)
Best assists
Canada M. Schaefer (2 Assists) , 
Canada L. Stanley (2 Assists)

New York Rangers - New York Islanders Key Points

  1. The Islanders have won just 2 of their last 10 games
  2. There have been under 6.5 goals in 4 of the last 5 Rangers-Islanders matchups
  3. There have been under 6.5 goals in each of Rangers 4 games this season
  4. The Islanders have lost their last 5 road games

Our New York Rangers vs New York Islanders Prediction

Rivalry games can be extremely tough to predict, especially in the early stages of the season. That being said, we do think that the Rangers have a slight edge over their rivals, especially in attack. 

Mike Sullivan's team have been playing with a lot of confidence in their opening games, so we are tipping them to continue their winning run and move to 4-1 for the season. 

The Islanders are not a team blessed with much attacking firepower, so despite their impressive 6-0 win over a dreadful New Jersey team, we are not expecting them to have much joy in front of goal on Tuesday night. 

Our prediction for New York Rangers vs New York Islanders is: Rangers to win and under 6.5 goals.

Prediction:

 

Rangers to win and under 6.5 goals

+295
$150 offered for betting!

A Welcome Bonus for New York Rangers vs New York Islanders!

DraftKings Welcome Bonus 150

Looking to place a bet on New York Rangers vs New York Islanders? For this NHL match, DraftKings will treat you to an exclusive offer: $150 in bonus bets, no promo code needed! Take advantage while you still can!

$150 in bonus bets for New York Rangers vs New York Islanders!

All tips are fully researched and given in good faith, but profits cannot be guaranteed.