Toronto Blue Jays vs New York Yankees Prediction & Picks - MLB

USA - MLB

Toronto Blue Jays
9/5/25 19:05
New York Yankees

Prediction:

 

The Yankees -1.5 Runs

+152
$300 offered for betting!

New customers only | Commercial content | 21+ age limit | T&Cs apply

 by Lou Aguila in MLB Picks

The Toronto Blue Jays have beaten the New York Yankees in six of their last seven meetings.

Will the Yankees finally get the better of the Blue Jays in this crucial series beginning Friday at Yankee Stadium?

Current Form:

The Yankees, who are 9-2 in their last 11 games, are the favorites at -134. New York compiled a 16-12 record in August and has won 2 of their first 3 games in September to bump their record up to 78-62, three games behind the 81-59 Blue Jays in the AL East standings. The Yankees have averaged 5.7 runs per game on a .240 batting average while commanding an elite 3.40 ERA in their last five games.

The Blue Jays took the last two games in their series with the Cincinnati Reds this week to stay in front of the Yankees in the AL East title race. After scoring 25 runs in the last two games, Toronto improves to 7.8 runs per game while batting .326 across their last five games. Toronto’s pitching form has been a little disappointing, though. Over the same five-game stretch, the Blue Jays have posted a 5.28 ERA and 1.49 WHIP - significantly higher than their season numbers of 4.29 ERA and 1.26 WHIP.

Toronto Blue Jays vs New York Yankees Form

Table

Teams % P W L
3
Toronto Blue Jays
Toronto Blue Jays
0.573 143 82 61
6
New York Yankees
New York Yankees
0.559 143 80 63

Toronto Blue Jays and New York Yankees Latest Matches

Toronto Blue Jays
Toronto Blue Jays Latest matches
L L W L W W
Victories

3/6 (50%)

Defeats

3/6 (50%)

Sep 3, 2025 - MLB

Toronto Blue Jays
13 :  9
Cincinnati Reds

Sep 2, 2025 - MLB

Toronto Blue Jays
12 :  9
Cincinnati Reds

Sep 1, 2025 - MLB

Toronto Blue Jays
4 :  5
Cincinnati Reds

Aug 31, 2025 - MLB

Milwaukee Brewers
4 :  8
Toronto Blue Jays

Aug 30, 2025 - MLB

Milwaukee Brewers
4 :  1
Toronto Blue Jays

Aug 29, 2025 - MLB

Milwaukee Brewers
7 :  2
Toronto Blue Jays
W L W L L W
Victories

3/6 (50%)

Defeats

3/6 (50%)

Aug 31, 2025 - MLB

Milwaukee Brewers
4 :  8
Toronto Blue Jays

Aug 30, 2025 - MLB

Milwaukee Brewers
4 :  1
Toronto Blue Jays

Aug 29, 2025 - MLB

Milwaukee Brewers
7 :  2
Toronto Blue Jays

Aug 27, 2025 - MLB

Minnesota Twins
8 :  9
Toronto Blue Jays

Aug 26, 2025 - MLB

Minnesota Twins
7 :  5
Toronto Blue Jays

Aug 25, 2025 - MLB

Minnesota Twins
4 :  10
Toronto Blue Jays
W W L L W W
Victories

4/6 (67%)

Defeats

2/6 (33%)

Sep 3, 2025 - MLB

Toronto Blue Jays
13 :  9
Cincinnati Reds

Sep 2, 2025 - MLB

Toronto Blue Jays
12 :  9
Cincinnati Reds

Sep 1, 2025 - MLB

Toronto Blue Jays
4 :  5
Cincinnati Reds

Aug 24, 2025 - MLB

Toronto Blue Jays
3 :  5
Miami Marlins

Aug 23, 2025 - MLB

Toronto Blue Jays
7 :  6
Miami Marlins

Aug 22, 2025 - MLB

Toronto Blue Jays
5 :  2
Miami Marlins
New York Yankees
New York Yankees Latest matches
W W L W L W
Victories

4/6 (67%)

Defeats

2/6 (33%)

Sep 4, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
8 :  4
Houston Astros

Sep 3, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
7 :  8
Houston Astros

Sep 2, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
7 :  1
Houston Astros

Aug 31, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
2 :  3
Chicago White Sox

Aug 30, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
5 :  3
Chicago White Sox

Aug 29, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
10 :  2
Chicago White Sox
L L W W W W
Victories

4/6 (67%)

Defeats

2/6 (33%)

Aug 27, 2025 - MLB

Washington Nationals
2 :  11
New York Yankees

Aug 26, 2025 - MLB

Washington Nationals
1 :  5
New York Yankees

Aug 25, 2025 - MLB

Washington Nationals
5 :  10
New York Yankees

Aug 24, 2025 - MLB

Boston Red Sox
2 :  7
New York Yankees

Aug 23, 2025 - MLB

Boston Red Sox
12 :  1
New York Yankees

Aug 22, 2025 - MLB

Boston Red Sox
1 :  0
New York Yankees
W W L W W L
Victories

4/6 (67%)

Defeats

2/6 (33%)

Sep 4, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
8 :  4
Houston Astros

Sep 3, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
7 :  8
Houston Astros

Sep 2, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
7 :  1
Houston Astros

Aug 31, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
2 :  3
Chicago White Sox

Aug 30, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
5 :  3
Chicago White Sox

Aug 29, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
10 :  2
Chicago White Sox

Toronto Blue Jays against New York Yankees : Head to Head (H2H)

Toronto Blue Jays

83 %

New York Yankees

17 %

Jul 23, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
4 :  8
Toronto Blue Jays

Jul 22, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
5 :  4
Toronto Blue Jays

Jul 21, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
1 :  4
Toronto Blue Jays

Jul 3, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
5 :  8
Toronto Blue Jays

Jul 2, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
9 :  11
Toronto Blue Jays

Jul 1, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
5 :  12
Toronto Blue Jays

Toronto Blue Jays - New York Yankees Key Points

  1. NY Yankees is 4-1 SU in its last 5 games when playing at home against Toronto.
  2. NY Yankees is 9-2 SU in its last 11 games.
  3. Toronto is 6-1 SU in its last 7 games against NY Yankees.
  4. Toronto is 1-4 SU in its last 5 games when playing on the road against NY Yankees.

Our Toronto Blue Jays vs New York Yankees Prediction

I am taking the Yankees to cover the -1.5 run spread at home. New York is 8-2 against the spread in their last 10 games and 3-0 ATS in their last three home games. Moreover, the Yankees are 4-1 in its last 5 games when playing at home against Toronto.

Yankees RHP Cam Schlitter is boasting a 1.26 ERA over his last five starts and has only allowed one run over his last 18.2 innings across three starts. On the contrary, Blue Jays RHP Kevin Gausman failed to lead Toronto to a win in his last four mound appearances, though he still carries a formidable 2.81 ERA over his last five starts.

This three-game showpiece could dictate the outcome of this year’s AL East title race. Toronto, New York, and Boston are locked in a frantic three-way race that could become messier at the conclusion of this series. The Yankees, who played in the World Series a year ago, are always dangerous at this time of the year because of their championship pedigree and the firepower that can tilt the balance of power anytime..

Our betting prediction for the New York Yankees vs. the Toronto Blue Jays: the Yankees -1.5 Runs.

Prediction:

 

The Yankees -1.5 Runs

+152
$300 offered for betting!

Grab an extra $300 for your Toronto Blue Jays vs New York Yankees wager!

Bet $5, Get $300

Get ready to experience the thrill of the game with FanDuel's exciting welcome offer, available for use on the Toronto Blue Jays vs New York Yankees matchup!

A minimum bet of $5 will qualify for $300 in bonus bets if your bet wins! This offer is a golden opportunity for new users. Don't miss out on this limited-time deal to enhance your sports betting experience with some extra oomph! Jump into the action today and let FanDuel take your sports engagement to the next level!

$300 available for Toronto Blue Jays vs New York Yankees

All tips are fully researched and given in good faith, but profits cannot be guaranteed.

Toronto Blue Jays vs New York Yankees Picks