New York Mets vs New York Yankees Prediction & Picks - MLB

USA - MLB

New York Mets
5/17/25 13:05
New York Yankees

Prediction:

 

Total Under 9.5 Runs

-115
$1500 offered for betting!

New customers only | Commercial content | 21+ age limit | T&Cs apply

 by Lou Aguila | in MLB Picks

The New York Yankees will for two in a row against their subway rival, the New York Mets, in Game 2 of their series on Saturday at Yankee Stadium.

The Yankees are now 4-1 in their last five games, and this includes the morale-boosting win over the Mets 6-2 on Friday. Once again, the Yankees dealt the most damage from the mound. Starter Carlos Rodon pitched for 5 innings, allowing 1 earned run and striking out 5. The Yankees' bullpen, which is giving up a 1.35 ERA over their last five games, blanked the Mets over the last four innings to get their team the victory. The Yankees improved their record to 26-18, five games clear of their closest rival, the Boston Red Sox, who are 22-24.

The Mets have absorbed back-to-back games, but the loss to the Yankees is without the more painful one since it’s all about bragging right in this fascinating series between New York rivals. The Mets are also at the top of their division with a 28-17 record. They are pitching an outstanding 2.84 ERA and batting .253, making them a two-way juggernaut in the MLB this season.

New York Mets vs New York Yankees Form

Table

Teams % P W L
2
New York Mets
New York Mets
0.63 46 29 17
8
New York Yankees
New York Yankees
0.578 45 26 19

New York Mets and New York Yankees Latest Matches

New York Mets
New York Mets Latest matches
L W W W L L
Victories

3/6 (50%)

Defeats

3/6 (50%)

May 16, 2025 - MLB

New York Mets
2 :  6
New York Yankees

May 14, 2025 - MLB

Pittsburgh Pirates
4 :  0
New York Mets

May 13, 2025 - MLB

Pittsburgh Pirates
1 :  2
New York Mets

May 12, 2025 - MLB

Pittsburgh Pirates
3 :  4
New York Mets

May 11, 2025 - MLB

Chicago Cubs
2 :  6
New York Mets

May 10, 2025 - MLB

Chicago Cubs
6 :  5
New York Mets
W L W W W L
Victories

4/6 (67%)

Defeats

2/6 (33%)

May 14, 2025 - MLB

Pittsburgh Pirates
4 :  0
New York Mets

May 13, 2025 - MLB

Pittsburgh Pirates
1 :  2
New York Mets

May 12, 2025 - MLB

Pittsburgh Pirates
3 :  4
New York Mets

May 11, 2025 - MLB

Chicago Cubs
2 :  6
New York Mets

May 10, 2025 - MLB

Chicago Cubs
6 :  5
New York Mets

May 9, 2025 - MLB

Chicago Cubs
2 :  7
New York Mets
L L W W L L
Victories

2/6 (33%)

Defeats

4/6 (67%)

May 16, 2025 - MLB

New York Mets
2 :  6
New York Yankees

May 7, 2025 - MLB

New York Mets
7 :  1
Arizona Diamondbacks

May 6, 2025 - MLB

New York Mets
1 :  5
Arizona Diamondbacks

May 5, 2025 - MLB

New York Mets
5 :  4
Arizona Diamondbacks

May 4, 2025 - MLB

New York Mets
4 :  5
St. Louis Cardinals

May 4, 2025 - MLB

New York Mets
5 :  6
St. Louis Cardinals
New York Yankees
New York Yankees Latest matches
L W W W L W
Victories

4/6 (67%)

Defeats

2/6 (33%)

May 16, 2025 - MLB

New York Mets
2 :  6
New York Yankees

May 14, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
3 :  2
Seattle Mariners

May 13, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
1 :  2
Seattle Mariners

May 12, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
11 :  5
Seattle Mariners

May 11, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
12 :  2
Athletics

May 10, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
7 :  11
Athletics
L L L W W W
Victories

3/6 (50%)

Defeats

3/6 (50%)

May 16, 2025 - MLB

New York Mets
2 :  6
New York Yankees

May 7, 2025 - MLB

San Diego Padres
3 :  4
New York Yankees

May 6, 2025 - MLB

San Diego Padres
3 :  12
New York Yankees

May 5, 2025 - MLB

San Diego Padres
4 :  3
New York Yankees

May 4, 2025 - MLB

Tampa Bay Rays
7 :  5
New York Yankees

May 3, 2025 - MLB

Tampa Bay Rays
3 :  2
New York Yankees
L W W W W L
Victories

4/6 (67%)

Defeats

2/6 (33%)

May 14, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
3 :  2
Seattle Mariners

May 13, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
1 :  2
Seattle Mariners

May 12, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
11 :  5
Seattle Mariners

May 11, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
12 :  2
Athletics

May 10, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
7 :  11
Athletics

May 9, 2025 - MLB

New York Yankees
10 :  2
Athletics

New York Mets against New York Yankees : Head to Head (H2H)

New York Mets

83 %

New York Yankees

17 %

May 16, 2025 - MLB

New York Mets
2 :  6
New York Yankees

Mar 24, 2025 - MLB Spring Training

New York Yankees
6 :  6
New York Mets

Jul 24, 2024 - MLB

New York Mets
12 :  3
New York Yankees

Jul 23, 2024 - MLB

New York Mets
3 :  2
New York Yankees

Jun 26, 2024 - MLB

New York Yankees
2 :  12
New York Mets

Jun 25, 2024 - MLB

New York Yankees
7 :  9
New York Mets

New York Mets - New York Yankees Key Points

  1. The total has gone UNDER in 10 of NY Yankees' last 13 games at home.
  2. The total has gone UNDER in 6 of NY Yankees' last 8 games when playing at home against NY Mets.
  3. The total has gone UNDER in 4 of NY Mets' last 5 games on the road.
  4. The total has gone UNDER in 6 of NY Mets' last 8 games when playing on the road against NY Yankees.

Our New York Mets vs New York Yankees Prediction

Fearless Forecast: Mets, Yankees tussle it up in a low-scoring Game 2

The Under at 9.5 total runs really looks appetizing now that we know who will be the starting pitchers for both teams. The Yankees will send Clark Schmidt (4.72 ERA), who has guided his team to 4 wins in his last 5 starts. The Mets counter with Griffin Canning (2.36 ERA), who has been virtually unhittable over his last five starts. Although the Yankees are averaging 6.5 runs per game over their last five assignments, the team hasn’t scored more than 3 runs in each of their last three games when facing Canning. Meanwhile, the Mets are posting barely 4 runs per game in their last 5 games. The total has gone UNDER in 4 of the NY Mets' last 5 games on the road and 10 of the NY Yankees' last 13 games at home.

Our betting prediction for the New York Mets vs. the New York Yankees: Total Under 9.5 Runs

Prediction:

 

Total Under 9.5 Runs

-115
$1500 offered for betting!

Don't miss out on a your rewards for the New York Mets vs New York Yankees matchup.

BetMGM Rewards

Looking to bet on New York Mets vs New York Yankees? For this MLB matchup, BetMGM is offering rewards for every dollar you spend on match wagers. Win or lose, your wager goes further with BetMGM rewards. 

Signing up for BetMGM couldn't be easier, click here to get started today!

Rewards for the New York Mets vs New York Yankees match!

All tips are fully researched and given in good faith, but profits cannot be guaranteed.

New York Mets vs New York Yankees Picks