Columbus Crew vs New York Red Bulls Prediction & Picks - Major League Soccer

USA - Major League Soccer

Columbus Crew
9/12/26 19:30
New York Red Bulls

Prediction:

 

Under 3.5 Goals

-137
$200 offered for betting!

New customers only | Commercial content | 21+ age limit | T&Cs apply

 by Bradley Gibbs | in Major League Soccer Picks

This is a Major League Soccer game between two teams that suffered damaging defeats during the week. After bouncing back to win last weekend, the Crew came unstuck against DC United, while the visitors, who are now without a win in six league games, lost to LAFC, delivering a particularly toothless effort in the process. Both teams need to improve, but can either get the job done? 

Looking at the lines ahead of this fixture, 'Under 3.5 Goals' appeals significantly at odds of -137, which are too generous to ignore. Both creatively and in terms of end product, the visitors are in shocking form, while the hosts have not exactly been at their flowing best offensively in recent weeks, leaving us to conclude that a relative lack of goals is more likely than the early odds would have us believe. 

Columbus Crew vs New York Red Bulls Form

Table

Teams Pts P W D L GD
25 New York Red Bulls
27 24 7 6 11 -16
27 Columbus Crew
23 24 6 5 13 -6

Columbus Crew and New York Red Bulls Latest Matches

Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew Latest matches
L L L L W L
Victories

1/6 (17%)

Draw

0/6 (0%)

Defeats

5/6 (83%)

Average stats (Last 6 matchs)

3.33 Total goals
67% BTTS
1.33 Goals scored
2 Goals conceded
83% Over 2.5
17% Under 2.5

Sep 9, 2026 - Major League Soccer

DC United
2 :  1
Columbus Crew

Sep 5, 2026 - Major League Soccer

Columbus Crew
3 :  0
Colorado Rapids

Aug 30, 2026 - Major League Soccer

Columbus Crew
1 :  3
New England Revolution

Aug 26, 2026 - Leagues Cup

CF America
2 :  0
Columbus Crew

Aug 22, 2026 - Major League Soccer

Nashville SC
3 :  2
Columbus Crew

Aug 19, 2026 - Major League Soccer

Columbus Crew
1 :  2
CF Montreal
W W D L L W
Victories

3/6 (50%)

Draw

1/6 (17%)

Defeats

2/6 (33%)

Average stats (Last 6 matchs)

3.17 Total goals
83% BTTS
1.83 Goals scored
1.33 Goals conceded
83% Over 2.5
17% Under 2.5

Sep 5, 2026 - Major League Soccer

Columbus Crew
3 :  0
Colorado Rapids

Aug 30, 2026 - Major League Soccer

Columbus Crew
1 :  3
New England Revolution

Aug 19, 2026 - Major League Soccer

Columbus Crew
1 :  2
CF Montreal

Aug 11, 2026 - Leagues Cup

Columbus Crew
1 :  1
Pumas UNAM

Aug 7, 2026 - Leagues Cup

Columbus Crew
2 :  1
CF Pachuca

Aug 4, 2026 - Leagues Cup

Columbus Crew
3 :  1
Atlas FC
D D L L L L
Victories

0/6 (0%)

Draw

2/6 (33%)

Defeats

4/6 (67%)

Average stats (Last 6 matchs)

3.33 Total goals
83% BTTS
1.17 Goals scored
2.17 Goals conceded
67% Over 2.5
33% Under 2.5

Sep 9, 2026 - Major League Soccer

DC United
2 :  1
Columbus Crew

Aug 26, 2026 - Leagues Cup

CF America
2 :  0
Columbus Crew

Aug 22, 2026 - Major League Soccer

Nashville SC
3 :  2
Columbus Crew

Aug 15, 2026 - Major League Soccer

Charlotte FC
3 :  1
Columbus Crew

Aug 1, 2026 - Major League Soccer

Inter Miami
2 :  2
Columbus Crew

May 16, 2026 - Major League Soccer

Philadelphia Union
1 :  1
Columbus Crew
New York Red Bulls
New York Red Bulls Latest matches
L L D L D L
Victories

0/6 (0%)

Draw

2/6 (33%)

Defeats

4/6 (67%)

Average stats (Last 6 matchs)

2 Total goals
50% BTTS
0.5 Goals scored
1.5 Goals conceded
33% Over 2.5
67% Under 2.5

Sep 9, 2026 - Major League Soccer

Los Angeles FC
2 :  0
New York Red Bulls

Sep 5, 2026 - Major League Soccer

Seattle Sounders
0 :  0
New York Red Bulls

Aug 29, 2026 - Major League Soccer

New York Red Bulls
1 :  3
Philadelphia Union

Aug 22, 2026 - Major League Soccer

New York Red Bulls
1 :  1
Chicago Fire

Aug 19, 2026 - Major League Soccer

New York Red Bulls
0 :  1
Nashville SC

Aug 15, 2026 - Major League Soccer

Atlanta United Fc
2 :  1
New York Red Bulls
D L W L D L
Victories

1/6 (17%)

Draw

2/6 (33%)

Defeats

3/6 (50%)

Average stats (Last 6 matchs)

2.67 Total goals
67% BTTS
1 Goals scored
1.67 Goals conceded
33% Over 2.5
67% Under 2.5

Aug 29, 2026 - Major League Soccer

New York Red Bulls
1 :  3
Philadelphia Union

Aug 22, 2026 - Major League Soccer

New York Red Bulls
1 :  1
Chicago Fire

Aug 19, 2026 - Major League Soccer

New York Red Bulls
0 :  1
Nashville SC

Aug 1, 2026 - Major League Soccer

New York Red Bulls
3 :  2
Orlando City SC

Jul 25, 2026 - Major League Soccer

New York Red Bulls
0 :  2
Charlotte FC

May 16, 2026 - Major League Soccer

New York Red Bulls
1 :  1
New York City
W W L L D L
Victories

2/6 (33%)

Draw

1/6 (17%)

Defeats

3/6 (50%)

Average stats (Last 6 matchs)

2.67 Total goals
67% BTTS
1.17 Goals scored
1.5 Goals conceded
67% Over 2.5
33% Under 2.5

Sep 9, 2026 - Major League Soccer

Los Angeles FC
2 :  0
New York Red Bulls

Sep 5, 2026 - Major League Soccer

Seattle Sounders
0 :  0
New York Red Bulls

Aug 15, 2026 - Major League Soccer

Atlanta United Fc
2 :  1
New York Red Bulls

Jul 22, 2026 - Major League Soccer

Philadelphia Union
3 :  1
New York Red Bulls

May 23, 2026 - Major League Soccer

Sporting Kansas City
1 :  2
New York Red Bulls

May 9, 2026 - Major League Soccer

Chicago Fire
1 :  3
New York Red Bulls

Columbus Crew against New York Red Bulls : Head to Head (H2H)

Columbus Crew

33 %

Draw

33 %

New York Red Bulls

33 %

Average stats (last H2H results)

3.17
Total goals
66.67%
BTTS
1.67
Goals scored
1.5
Goals conceded
66.67%
Over 2.5
33.33%
Under 2.5

May 13, 2026 - Major League Soccer

New York Red Bulls
3 :  2
Columbus Crew

Oct 18, 2025 - Major League Soccer

Columbus Crew
3 :  1
New York Red Bulls

Aug 30, 2025 - Major League Soccer

New York Red Bulls
0 :  0
Columbus Crew

Nov 3, 2024 - Major League Soccer

New York Red Bulls
2 :  2
Columbus Crew

Oct 29, 2024 - Major League Soccer

Columbus Crew
0 :  1
New York Red Bulls

Oct 19, 2024 - Major League Soccer

New York Red Bulls
2 :  3
Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew vs New York Red Bulls Picks

Players list

Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
Goalkeeper

P. Schulte

Defender

C. Ruvalcaba

M. Amundsen

B. Lennon

M. Farsi

Midfielder

T. Habroune

T. Karumanchi

S. Zawadzki

S. Rodriguez

D. Chambost

Forward

J. Martinez

New York Red Bulls
New York Red Bulls
Goalkeeper

E. Horvath

Defender

D. Nealis

J. Che

J. Bazan

D. Padelford

Midfielder

A. Mehmeti

E. Forsberg

Forward

M. Sofo

C. Cowell

E. Choupo-Moting

D. Nelich

Substitutes

Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
Goalkeeper

L. Pruter

N. Hagen

Defender

S. Moreira

E. Bailly

Midfielder

A. Gomes

B. Mendez

Forward

J. Thiare

L. Giaccone

G. Tapia

New York Red Bulls
New York Red Bulls
Goalkeeper

J. McCarthy

Defender

T. Parker

J. Marshall-Rutty

Midfielder

S. Kone

D. Ruiz

Forward

C. Harper

J. Ruvalcaba

J. Hall

M. Jimenez

Missing players

Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
Forward

W. Abou Ali

New York Red Bulls
New York Red Bulls
Goalkeeper

A. Marcucci

Midfielder

R. Donkor

Most goals and assists

CD Huachipato Columbus Crew
CD Huachipato New York Red Bulls
Top Goalscorer
Uruguay D. Rossi (6 Goals)
Top Goalscorer
USA J. Hall (9 Goals)
Best assists
USA M. Arfsten (4 Assists)
Best assists
USA C. Cowell (5 Assists)

Columbus Crew - New York Red Bulls Key Points

  1. Less than four goals have been scored in three of the last four competitive games played by the Columbus Crew.
  2. More than three goals have been scored in just one of the last six MLS games played by the New York Red Bulls.
  3. The visitors have scored just two goals in their last five MLS games.
  4. The hosts have scored more than once in just one of their last four competitive home games.

Our Columbus Crew vs New York Red Bulls Prediction

In recent weeks, we've seen an alarming lack of quality in the final third from these two teams, so much so that the early market seems to be overestimating the chances of a relatively high-scoring game. Sure, you wouldn't exactly say that either side is defensively sound, but neither team is creating or scoring a lot, so this could very easily be a low-scoring encounter. 

In two of their last three at home, the hosts have created less than 0.50 expected goals, while the visitors have produced xG totals of just 0.43 and 0.91 in their last two on the road. 

Our Columbus Crew vs New York Red Bulls Pick: Under 3.5 Goals.

Prediction:

 

Under 3.5 Goals

-137
$200 offered for betting!

A Welcome Bonus for Columbus Crew vs New York Red Bulls!

DraftKings Welcome Bonus

Looking to place a bet on Columbus Crew vs New York Red Bulls? For this Major League Soccer match, DraftKings will treat you to an exclusive offer: $200 in bonus bets, no promo code needed! Take advantage while you still can!

$200 in bonus bets for Columbus Crew vs New York Red Bulls!

All tips are fully researched and given in good faith, but profits cannot be guaranteed.